9mm vs 357 sig

In comparing the energy levels of premium self-defense ammunition, the muzzle energy of 584 ft⋅lbf (792 J) of the 125 grains (8.1 g) 1,450 feet per second (440 m/s) .357 SIG load is greater than either the 475 ft⋅lbf (644 J) generated by a 155 grains (10.0 g) 1,175 feet per second (358 m/s) Speer GoldDot .40 S&W load or the 400 ft⋅lbf (540 J) generated by a 180 grains (12 g) 985 feet per second (300 m/s) Speer GoldDot .40 S&W load.[28]. Shoot lots and stay safe. Takedown for cleaning is very easy. The vast majority are also very patriotic.These patriots despise the loss of liberty given by God and enshrined in the Second Amendment to the US Constitution. The P365 has become my EDC primarily because of capacity. Glock is just a piece of plastic, i prefer my pistols to be metal! Follow up shots are fast and accurate. The .357 SIG was designed to mimic the .357 Mag stopping power and velocity and make it available in a magazine-fed, semi-automatic pistol, as the .357 Mag is considered a revolver round. Apart from the .22lr, I would consider using any of them for self-defense. At the time, Glock used a contractor to make the barrels. Glock told me that it was a shooter or ammo issue. Glocks are the one gun that never need to defend or prove their reliability. Good article. It has hundreds of rounds through it and still has yet to have a malfunction or issue. To start we need to look at the history of each cartridge..357 Sig History. Of course the Sig won. I would suggest having several individuals fire groups for each firearm, to help account for existing-experience and fit/function biases. We Americans are rapidly losing freedoms once cherished and taken for granted. Well, when Dallas PD had 500 of them with similar issues, they replaced my barrel. Though the Taurus isn’t near as popular, the two are more similar on paper with the exception of price. [9] However, the cartridge and chamber drawing in the ANSI/SAAMI American National Standards also clearly shows the cartridge headspacing on the cartridge mouth. I have large hands and like the way it feels and shoots. On the range shooting steel targets at speed, all three guns functioned flawlessly. The Glock was good, but all shots to the left. Is hands down best and better than my Glock 43. The P365 clearly wins in this category. In this article I will be comparing two kinds of similar but very different handgun calibers: the 9×19 Parabellum and the .357 SIG. “Freedom of choice ” , Sig didn’t do anything new here. $20 and about a minute of your time brings it down to a sweet 3.5-4.0 pull. The Sig, while being very short in height overall has the longest front strap on the grip, allowing the shooter to get a better handle on the gun. Buzz, In 2003 the Pennsylvania Game Commission began issuing its Game Wardens Glock 31 gen3 pistols chambered in .357 SIG, but in late 2019 will be transitioning to Glock 31 gen4 chambered in the same caliber. Then Remington introduced the unsuccessful .22 Remington Jet (1961), which necked a .357 Magnum case down to a .22 caliber bullet, and the .221 Remington Fireball (1963), a shortened version of their .222 Remington. Busted firing pin notwithstanding. My own experience with the P365 thus far has been positive. The well stippled little grip is easy to get a hold of and hang on to while shooting. Some would say that you get what you pay for, but have to question that logic here. The XDs – which I really wanted to love, shot the worst and felt the worst. I have been carry the SiG 290 for several years now, a great gun with zero problems. Performance is similar to the 9×23mm Winchester. Personally, I know that most of the talk centers on the magazine capacity, but I would still tell people to carry the gun that they shoot best. The size and capacity of this plastic gun makes it sound attractive and every article I have read says this is a great gun. If you have large hands it might not fit you as well as it fits me but if you have small to medium hands it might be the answer to all of your needs in an EDC pistol. Still – Sig, as a company, while not perfect (who is!?) Since the P229 has a smaller grip area, it is quite easier to conceal. You can research the dozens of other liberties lost over the last 50+ years. Remember “Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for dinner; Liberty is a well armed lamb protesting the vote”, I think living here in California I can say from experience that they really chip away at liberty in every aspect of life. [citation needed] The Paramus Police Department in New Jersey also issues the SIG P229 in .357 SIG. 2) why use the older shield and not the newer version? An average muzzle velocity of 9mm ammunition, that being the energy the bullet leaves the barrel with, is around 1,200 feet per second (commonly abbreviated as … Anyway, I went in completely unbiased – was hoping to not like the Sig because of the issues. Modern gun culture has degenerated into false idolatry, and excuses for indulging in Boy Toys. What gun did many really like the most. Handgun rounds in the .38 caliber family have always been the most popular, but since some (.38 Special, .380) are a bit weak the most popular are .357 Magnum vs 9mm.Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self … Different selections for different needs of the moment and to give the girls the proper rotation in my edc. Teach a kid, teach a mom, especially a single mom. Related Tags: Key: Change in size and trigger made a huge difference for me. It’s winning feature was its grouping– nothing short of amazing for a baby 9. Example, P320, P365. If you take the P365 route, you're stuck with 9mm while the P320 Compact offers 9mm, 40 S&W, and 357 SIG as caliber options. Be safe out there. I think other gun company people are making negative comments about the Sig. i like the smith better had one for 8 years with no issue. The casing of the .357 SIG is both thicker and longer than the .40 S&W (when comparing the .40 vs. .357 SIG, the casing lengths differ by .005 inches) and more resembles the 10mm casing. The "Accurate Powder" reloading manual claims that it is "without a doubt the most ballistically consistent handgun cartridge we have ever worked with. Each of us have our preference. of the 9mm cartridge , nor would I want a striker fired Think about it for a minute, 10+1 in the Sig is as many rounds as a single stack 9mm 1911 holds. Purchased it along with the extended magazine. All these guns are very capable of engaging targets at defensive distances at speed with good shot placement. (Isaiah 41:10 So do not fear, for I am with you; do not be dismayed, for I am your God. [citation needed] The Coral Springs Police Department in Florida uses the Sig P226 and P229 Enhanced Elite pistols chambered in .357 SIG. But their popularity has declined due to the higher capacity and quicker reloading of semi-automatic pistols in the 9mm Parabellum, the .357 SIG, the .40 S&W, the .45 ACP, or the .45 GAP versions. These guns were shipped with major problems, eventually confidence wanes and takes time to rebuild trust. The sig 365 wasnt avaliable when i made my choice. At an average cost of 40 cents per round for defensive ammo, that’s $800 – $1,200 in added costs just for me to prove to myself that the next pull of the trigger won’t be my last. Drag marks causing broken strikers, sights, etc. The P365’s front sight was definitely fast to pick up and track. I had one of the first Glock 19’s when they first came out. i carry the p.c. [42], Ottawa, Kansas Police Department carried the Glock 31 .357 SIG, but has since moved to the Glock 17 GEN 4 9mm.[43][44]. I thought the author was a Sig sales rep. Don’t get me wrong, the Sig is a fine sub compact, but the Kahr and the Springfield Hellcat should have been compared. I’ve tried all three of these pistols and IMO you missed the best in this category: the XD-S® 3.3″ Single Stack in 9mm. Hold it and shoot it if possible. Note: Underwood now also offers a standard pressure 65 gr .357 SIG Xtreme Defender (XD) round with a muzzle velocity of 2100 fps, muzzle energy of 636 ft. lbs. As an owner and senior, I have become increasingly intolerant of persons who falsely equate “Freedom,” or other cliched aphorisms meant to define Patriotism in any form, with a mandatory reverence towards firearms. It’s been quite reliable so far, had a couple failure-to-go-into-battery (by about 1/16″) when it was brand new, but that cleared up almost immediately and has been perfectly reliable since then with all types of ammo. the first 25 slow and deliberate, next ten slow at the face part of the target and 3 rounds of 5 shooting as quickly as I could. Now, which gun would you rather have? I only got rid of it because I got the TRP Operator. The P365 gets close with its 15 round extended magazine, … It used to be, and for the most part still is, that after firing 500 rounds of your favorite defensive ammo, you’d know that your new gun would be reliable. Thanks for your opinions on them. I have to agree with Mike Gardner. I’ll stick with HK for straight out of the box reliability. Bullets are a component of the cartridge as a whole. My P365 does demonstrate the extreme “firing pin” drag and base scratching of spent cartridges others have reported – leading to breakages in their P365 firing pins. The P365 will most likely be my next pistol purchase. I love sales. It appears that Kel-Tec and Kahr Arms really started a trend with Micro-9s. https://www.glockstore.com/Magazine-Extension-for-Glock-43. This review was nothing but a way to make Sig look good. Because of its relatively high velocity[13] for a handgun round, the .357 SIG has an unusually flat trajectory, extending the effective range. Bottom Line- both are outstanding examples of compact carry weapons. P365 bod 5/22/2018 less than 100 rounds broken striker. I realize it is a 380 which equates to a 9 MM short. Several sources have published contradicting information regarding .357 SIG headspacing. The posers might tell you otherwise. I sure wish they put the XDS into this test. Grip size difference is clear between Sig and S&W in this photo. Fool me once, shame on you, foool me twicce…. work better for others , allowing them to participate in Troublesome! I have small hands and have never been able to shoot any of these guns well until the P365. Many people seem to think the intention of the second amendment was to protect man’s right to hunt and target shoot. History of .357 Sig vs. 9mm. I am a Sig fan and own 3 but I am not willing to buy the 365 until Sig says they have found and solved the striker issue. Racking the slide on smaller 9mm guns can sometimes be a challenge due to having little to hang on too while having to overcome the short stiff recoil springs. All three guns are in a league by themselves. Not happy with a company that now seems to rely on it’s customers to do it’s quality control testing for them, at the customers expense, financially and life and limb. All I see and hear is nothing but problems with it. As a previous article here stated, the easiest gun to fire. So the winner was the XDS. I’ve owned and carried a P365 for over a year after having carried four other subcompacts for five years. However, due to the popularity of the 9mm caliber, 9x19mm is typically $0.05 to $0.10 cheaper per round. Some people think everyone weighs 250 pounds. Super weird that your G43 would have a malfunction with my actual everyday carry ammo when my Glock 43 eats it up without a hitch. Cannot do the practicing I like at a range and while Gunsite is not that far from where I live the desert is free . If we were to forever hold a grudge on a few hiccups in the beginning none of us would have AR-15’s now would we. I shot my 1st one up to 1500 rounds without a hitch then sold it,and bought a new one. I have shot ~300 rounds with the P365 without a single failure using Remington Golden Saber 147 gran, Federal HST 124 grain, and Hornady Critical Defense 124 grain. It appears they have set some new standards to be reached by others. Still shoots great no issues. I originally “wanted” the Sig, but IMO it didn’t match up in overall “feel”, grip, trigger, or quality (always a relative thing when talking about these mid-priced pistols). and a penetration depth of 17.5 inches. I stood back 62 yards with 23 rds of Hornady 115 XTP (my handloads) and was rewarded with 23 pings on a 11×20 IPSC steel plate, all center mass except for one I put in the left shoulder. The Sig with its 10 round flat or extended finger support magazine is 3 rounds above the S&W or 4 above the Glock. Grail… I wrote/posted a similar comment not to long ago on the Sig. Ideally would like a sig 232 in 9mm but since it doesnt exist this what we get. And the bulky take down lever was ridiculous. My issue is just the added weight of the more rounds when i am trying to make an EDC as light and small as possible. The SAAMI pressure limit for the .357 SIG is set at 275.80 MPa (40,000 psi), piezo pressure.[11]. After a little time warming up all 3 guns with some ball ammunition to get acquainted it was time to calm down and shoot some groups. TSC – temporary stretch cavity volume (ballistic gelatin). I had one of the first Glock 19\’s when they first came out. This is much less important to me now. The Sig P365 is the last Sig product I will ever spend my hard earned money on. S&W had the greatest sight radius due to rear sight reaching to the back of the slide. I highly, highly suggest shooting them and pulling them from concealment. I am a big Sig fan, but to not include the Hellcat!? The P226 is a full-sized pistol, while the Sig P229 is a compact, mid-sized pistol. I occasionally experienced bullet pull with my 9mm S&W 929 Miculek. I will strengthen you and help you; I will uphold you with my righteous right hand. The .357 SIG (designated as the 357 Sig by the SAAMI[2] and 357 SIG by the C.I.P. Taurus G2c is a quarter inch wider, it would be more comparable to a P320SC or a Glock G26 than any of these guns. Thank you! Developed in 1994, the new cartridge was named "357" to highlight its purpose: to duplicate the performance of 125-grain (8.1 g) .357 Magnum loads fired from 4-inch (100 mm)-barreled revolvers, in a cartridge designed to be used in a semi-automatic pistol with greater ammunition capacity than a revolver. Glock 43 for me. [citation needed] In doing so, the Texas DPS became the first government agency to deploy a firearm utilizing the then relatively new .357 SIG chambering. The rear sight is also well executed; the outside corners are rounded to prevent snagging and digging into your flesh when carrying concealed. I have a Sig 938 and a GSR in .45 bought used. Respect to it, capable, cheap, reliable, even versatile, but still a dinosaur. GunsAmerica never posted the comment. The only other conclusions I arrive at is that I liked the way the P365 grip feels better than the other two guns, but I shot the Glock 43 just a little bit faster, possibly due to previous familiarity. [citation needed] The Oklahoma Highway Patrol and Rhode Island State Police issue the SIG Sauer P226 in .357 SIG. At the time, Glock used a contractor to make the barrels. The bottleneck shape of the .357 SIG cartridge makes feeding problems almost non-existent. 357 Magnum vs. 357 SIG: These two calibers sound similar and while the performance can be about the same, they have very different uses. the PC model would have been a better comparison. I wondered about that, thinking the problem might have been overblown. I like sig but for the money….why not just carry a taurus g2c or g3c?? You omitted to mention MSRP ! [citation needed] The West Grove Borough Police Department, West Grove PA, also carry the SIG Sauer P229 in the .357 SIG caliber. I have pistols chambered in .22lr, 9mm Luger, .40 S7W, 357 SIG, and .45 ACP. It is measured in inches or in millimeters. If your uncle chose to not carry a firearm for more than hunting, that is his choice. All three guns shot accurately enough to be used in defensive situations, clearly, each gun had some likes and dislikes in the ammunition tested. Find yours and carry on. 380 vs 9mm price When comparing 380 ammo vs 9mm ammo, you would think the cheaper choice would be the 380, since there are lower costs in raw materials. however still bank my life on S&W. However, the 9mm Luger does not have the necking, and has a smaller case diameter. I was definitely the winner in that trade. It will be interesting to see if they are able to offer the P365 in other calibers like the Shield and Xds do. Not all apples but looking for something subcompact. Personally, I’m a revolver man , and am no fan The last 18 months have proven this. Keltec and Taurus and alther have made them for years before everyone caught on. Excellent accuracy and carrying capability. That being said, 9mm vs .357 Sig is worth exploring, if for no other reason than to crush some ballistic myths. My personal preference for a home defense handgun is a full-sized pistol chambered in .45 ACP. Despite their functional similarities, the Sig P226 and the Sig P229 have notable differences when it comes to sight radius length, barrel, and slide. I was not very accurate with the Glock or Sig, S&W shot well. It also has a flat trigger that is awesome. I took it to the range and shot it side by side with my Shield (Performance Center). Great comparison for sure but did I miss the barrel lengths? personal defense weapon . Loads with 9mm Luger brass with the Winchester JHP bullet averaged 0.0068-inches taper and for the Speer .357 SIG GDHP bullet 0.0065-inches taper. .357 Magnum Vs 9mm: Melee Of The Medium Bores. I refuse to carry a pistol with a grip extension. .357 SIG maximum C.I.P. This is where Sig’s P365 starts to pull away from the pack for me. Your comparative specification table lists the width of the P365 at 1.36″. Comment if you’d like a similar article done but including other pistols. “If one equates “freedom” with the absurdly low bar set before acquiring a gun”. Everyone of these firearms has extended magazines that can give you plenty of rounds if you are not prone to complete adrenaline-fueled, wild shot, ammo dumping at a threat. Couldn’t justify the new cost of a Sig. It’s as if they fire laser guided bullets with perfect reliability in my experience. Sig had made the leap into the deep end of the pool to compete with the well-established pillars of the micro market, the Smith & Wesson Shield, and the Glock 43 9mms. I’m all for everyone carrying and shooting the gun they like, but I’m not personally ready to jump on the Sig bandwagon. For the time being, I’ll stick with my Bersa Thunder 9 Pro Ultra Compact (that’s a mouthful). Was it sent by the manufacturer for testing and evaluation or was it purchased sight unseen through a dealer? The P365 did have the shortest sight radius as expected since it had the shortest overall length. Ronnie. It certainly looked and felt good, and it held more bullets than its rival competitors, but looks are sometimes deceiving. Whatever the reason, it shot the best and all three shot well for “Micro-Compacts” at that distance. He has been featured on several of Outdoor Channel’s Shooting Gallery episodes and on a Downrange TV series. I have a Sig 938, 226, and 229 and shoot a fair amount, never have I had a failure to feed or fire, and they are much more accurate than many other guns. Should we make it more difficult to buy an automobile? It looks like “Sig Quality” may be a thing of the past. the Sig p365. While it is based on a 10 mm case necked down to accept 0.355-inch (9.0 mm) bullets, the .357 SIG cartridge case is slightly longer than .40 S&W by 0.009 in (0.23 mm) to 0.020 in (0.51 mm) total. I agree some. The Virginia State Police has reported that attacking dogs have been stopped dead in their tracks by a single shot, whereas the former 147 grain 9 mm duty rounds would require multiple shots to incapacitate the animals. No right or wrong here any and all these choices are good choices, just my 2cents worth and what was important to me. In comparison to 9mm, .357 Sig … Other than the two failures with the large-mouthed bullets, all three of the guns ran 100% with both flush and extended magazines, with a wide variety of ammunition- these are highly reliable guns. lb Muzzle Velocity ft/sec. Im just here to piss ALL yall off! Flat point bullets are seldom used with other autoloader firearms because of feeding problems; however, such bullets are commonly seen in the .357 SIG chambering and are quite reliable, as are hollow-point bullets. The .357 SIG. Lot’s of good information though! They are all great guns and I have shot them all. 500 rounds, no issues. The Eutawville Police Department in South Carolina issues the Glock 31 in .357 SIG. I’m not willing to pay a high dollar price for a gun I need to start rebuilding to have confidence in it, nor will I trust my life to it until Sig proves the issue is gone. Never had a problem with mine!!! rulings the .357 SIG case can handle up to 305 MPa (44,236 psi) piezo pressure. Firearm vs hand ergonomics will play a role as well, so having folks with varying hand sizes/shapes test each firearm (preferably in the same controlled environment) will help counteract fit/function bias. Now, the P365 is having striker and trigger issues, and Sig is trying to act as if that is normal wear and tear on the pistol. Your comment make more sense than anything on the page. An ant could never defend himself from a man’s foot. The reason I don’t carry my Shield, Keltec or P290RS (unless I am in NY with their mag capacity limits) is capacity. Stay safe. I own a Shield and have shot just about every Glock out there including the 43. I went with shield 40, holds 7+1 of underwood 115g extreme defender rounds. So not a word about the tremendous amount of catastrophic failures in the 365? No mention of the Hellcat!? Patriotism is generally defined as love of country. I also have two XLs with Holosun red dots. I use mine for IWB carry. I shot the 365 and the 365XL and preferred the XL. [citation needed], However, in 2013 the Texas DPS decided to replace their .357 SIG handguns with 9mm handguns. Every other pistol is either a 10mm, 45acp or .40sw. If someone wants to kill himself, he will find a way to do so. 9mm vs 45 ACP Ballistics. But these are also the brands that advertise on GunsAmerica. Ten rounds of “maybe” vs seven rounds of “definitely.” Hmmm, tough choice. For Gen 1 customers who want to run a caliber other than 9mm, SIG will offer them a “complete Gen 2 upper receiver assembly at the same cost as a caliber exchange kit” — but only in .40 or .357 SIG. Should we , as So where did they hide all those extra rounds in the SIG? agreed. Mildest to shoot out of all of them and hardly any muzzle flip. But there’s so much to the Sig that you have to think that if there were no glaring issues, how anyone could say it’s not THE CCW weapon for all. Son is 5’8, 136 and only when he is carrying a weapon in bear country 4” 44mag or a 460 occasional Grizzly area you would never know he’s armed. Bought mine for $499.00 @ a brick & morter store. Not as many as the Sig, but more than 6. Exercise it and strengthen it. For example, the grip size and angle of a Glock 43 will fit better in some people’s hands, than a Shield or P365. IMHO the best concealed carry gun hands down ever made. Freedom should be dangerous not a system of infringement and “ common sense.”. Seriously! The Glock with its different grip angle required me to do a little adjusting of sight picture but was fast and accurate, though the magazine capacity only allowed me to put controlled pairs on each of 3 silhouettes then get only one of the plates from the plate rack. I would not trust that gun with my life. Gun Digest Buyer's Guide to Concealed-Carry Handguns By Jerry Ahern. These measurements were made with the shortest, non-extended magazines that are offered for each gun. The numbers above clearly show that Sig has produced a product that is within the same size and weight arena as its competitors. I have NEVER had a mis-feed, stove pipe, or any other failure of any sort. After examining all three represented in your article, I ended up purchasing the XD-S. The MSRP of $599 is a bit higher than the other guns but Sig brings a bit more to the game. Visit Smith & Wesson and learn more about the Shield by clicking Here. For mid-sized pistols … No comment on the broken strikers with the Sig? Bullet weights ranging from 115 to 150 grains (7.5 to 9.7 g) have been offered. Same with 1 of my last 7 jeeps….so let’s just make sure we buy a gen 2 if you want one and be happy. The smallest group overall was shot by the Glock 43 with the Federal ammunition. Your comment is is in no way relevant to the article. However, the pull weight to break the trigger on the P365 came in about a pound less than either of the two other guns and had very little over travel. Firearms are by far the worst example of this. The .357 vs 9mm is a comparison that features two of the more popular and well known cartridges. The Sig P365 wins this shootout in my humble opinion. [21][22] These measurements were performed with a Thompson Center Encore 1842 break-action, single-shot pistol/rifle, preventing differing barrel length definitions between semi-automatic pistols and revolvers giving revolvers a potential muzzle velocity advantage.[23]. I still have a Taurus 24/7 in 9mm bought it when they first came out. Many police departments who have utilized the .357 SIG round found that the flash was so significant that night vision was affected. The fun is over way to soon. Unfortunately this combination, Glock 43 and Federal 147 JHP ammunition also had the only malfunctions (2) during all the testing.

What Does Stradlater Do When Holden Keeps Provoking Him, Irish Wolfhound Bark, How To Remove Wax Buildup From Linoleum, Power Acoustik 2020, Madera News Missing Girl, Losi Trail Trekker Parts, Masterforce 56'' Tool Box, Kennedy Class 1 Modification 1,